Our Blogs

Yes, the police can force a blood draw. However, it’s not as straightforward as it sounds. Many people assume that if an officer demands a blood test, they have no choice but to comply. But the law is more complex. There are strict rules and conditions that law enforcement must follow before they can legally take your blood. They need either your consent, a warrant, or a legally justified reason to skip the warrant. This is where things get tricky. Police officers sometimes push the boundaries, assuming you don’t know your rights.

If you’ve been subjected to a forced blood draw or are facing criminal charges, don’t face it alone. At the Law Office of Andrew Bryant, our team is experienced in challenging unlawful evidence and advocating fiercely on your behalf. Contact our Colorado Springs, CO criminal defense attorney today to schedule a consultation.

Understanding Blood Draws in Criminal Investigations

Police often request blood draws in the following scenarios:

• DUI Arrests: When an officer suspects a driver is under the influence of alcohol or drugs.
• Serious Accidents: Especially when there are injuries or fatalities involved.
• Refusal of Other Tests: If a driver refuses a breathalyzer test, the officer may request a blood draw instead.

While these situations seem straightforward, the legality of forcing a blood draw is far more complicated.

Legal Grounds for Blood Draws

Express Consent Laws

In Colorado, when you get behind the wheel, you automatically agree to what is known as express consent. This means you agree to submit to chemical tests—like blood or breath tests—if an officer suspects you of driving under the influence. Refusing these tests can lead to automatic penalties, such as license suspension and increased legal consequences.\

However, express consent does not give law enforcement unlimited power. It simply means that refusing a test comes with consequences. This does not mean that they can force a blood draw without following legal procedures.

Search Warrants

Under the Fourth Amendment, you are protected against unreasonable searches and seizures, which include the taking of your blood. Therefore, in most cases, law enforcement must obtain a search warrant before performing a blood draw. Officers who obtain a warrant are legally allowed to perform a blood draw, even against your will.

There are limited situations where a warrantless, forced blood draw is permissible:

• Unconscious Drivers: If you’re unconscious or otherwise incapable of consenting, Colorado’s Express Consent law allows for a blood test to determine alcohol or drug content.
• Serious Offenses: If an officer has probable cause to believe you’ve committed certain serious offenses, such as vehicular homicide or assault, and you’re refusing testing, they may proceed with a forced blood draw.

To get a warrant, an officer must present evidence to a judge showing probable cause that you were driving under the influence. If approved, the warrant allows them to take a blood sample legally.

Exigent Circumstances

There are exceptions to the warrant requirement. In rare cases, police can bypass the need for a warrant under exigent circumstances—situations where waiting for a warrant could lead to the destruction of evidence.

For example, because alcohol or drugs naturally dissipate in the bloodstream over time, an officer may argue that waiting for a warrant could result in losing substantial evidence. However, this is not a free pass for law enforcement. Courts carefully scrutinize claims of exigent circumstances to ensure they are valid.

Legal Defenses

Challenging the Warrant

If the officer did not have enough evidence to justify the warrant, the blood draw could be deemed illegal. Mistakes in how the warrant was obtained or executed can invalidate the blood draw evidence.

Improper Procedures

Even with a valid warrant, the blood draw must be conducted according to legal and medical standards. If the blood draw was performed by someone who was not medically qualified. If the blood sample is improperly stored or contaminated, it may be deemed invalid.

Violation of Constitutional Rights

Forced blood draws must comply with the Fourth Amendment’s protection against unreasonable searches. If your rights were violated, your attorney could argue to have the evidence thrown out.

Consult a Colorado Springs Criminal Defense Lawyer

A forced blood draw can feel like a violation of your rights. It’s invasive, intimidating, and leaves you with more questions than answers. At the Law Office of Andrew Bryant, we know that behind every charge is a person with rights, fears, and a future worth fighting for.

At the Law Office of Andrew Bryant we dig deeper, challenging the validity of the blood draw, scrutinizing the procedures, and questioning every detail. We find the weak points that others might overlook and use them to build a powerful defense. Contact a seasoned Colorado Springs criminal defense lawyer at (719) 634-7353 or get in touch online. The sooner you act, the better your chances of protecting your rights and your future.